Anjali Katta is a student at Harvard Law School.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has ruled that removal protections for NLRB Administrative Law Judges (ALJs) and Board Members are unconstitutional. This ruling affirmed district court injunctions that halted unfair labor practice proceedings against three companies: SpaceX, Energy Transfer, and Findhelp. The Fifth Circuit held that being subject to an unconstitutional administrative proceeding was an irreparable harm that justified preliminary injunctions and halted the ULP cases from proceeding against the companies.
Currently, NLRB ALJs are protected by dual layers of ‘for-cause’ removal, and Board Members can only be removed for “neglect of duty or malfeasance.” The Fifth Circuit found these protections violate separation of powers by limiting presidential oversight, citing Free Enterprise Fund and Seila Law. The Court ruled that Humphrey’s Executor does not apply as ALJs are “inferior officers” and that the NLRB Board was distinct from the FTC as Board Members wield “substantial executive power”, are not subject to the same party balancing rules, and the NLRB’s structure and powers remove the Board from the narrow Humphrey’s Executor exception. The Court also rejected jurisdictional arguments that the Norris-LaGuardia Act prevented judicial interference into labor disputes as they found that constitutional challenges to agency structure do not meet the Act’s definition of a labor dispute.
The Fifth Circuit is the first federal court of appeals to rule the NLRA unconstitutional. However, despite the significance of this decision, little has changed for now. The ultimate answer will likely come from the Supreme Court, which is expected to weigh in—either through an appeal of this case or a related one, such as Wilcox v. Trump (as Ted and John have reported on).
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
November 19
Harvard academic workers end strike without contract; Reuters journalists authorize a strike; Spirit Airlines’ sale of employee data to Google for AI training approved.
November 18
Judge vacates foreign-student visa limits; DOL proposes QPAM relief; Supreme Court declines Nexstar appeal.
November 17
Amazon workers in Canada win company's first union contract in North America; NY law gives employees access to personnel records; D.C. Circuit looks to overturn Trump joint employer rule
November 16
FMCSA ordered to disburse $73 million in withheld highway funds to New York; Department of Labor final rule regarding large union financial disclosures issued six years after initial withdrawal is upheld; Department of Labor issues enforcement alert for physician ghost networks maintained by health plans.
November 15
Unions oppose Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader; Rockstar staff vote on unionization ahead of Grand Theft Auto VI’s release; New Jersey Education Association faces federal investigation.
November 12
Harvard graduate students go on strike; New York city mayor prepares to negotiate with the city's largest public union; the Trump administration proposes stringent rules for workers seeking benefits.