John Fry is a student at Harvard Law School.
Two sets of unfair labor practice proceedings against SpaceX are on hold, as two Fifth Circuit courts have issued preliminary injunctions against the NLRB pending the outcome of the company’s constitutional challenges to the agency.
As of late April, it appeared that SpaceX’s first challenge, filed in the Southern District of Texas, was being transferred to California after a protracted venue battle in which the Fifth Circuit narrowly declined to override the trial judge’s transfer order. However, over two months later, the trial judge has still not finalized the transfer. Furthermore, amid the venue dispute, the trial judge did not rule swiftly on SpaceX’s motion for a preliminary injunction against the NLRB, so the company appealed the matter to the Fifth Circuit, calling the trial judge’s delay an “effective denial” of the injunction. In a one-sentence order, the Fifth Circuit granted the injunction, despite the NLRB’s argument that the appeal lacked jurisdiction because the case was (ostensibly) bound for California.
On Wednesday, SpaceX also secured a similar injunction in the Western District of Texas, where it has filed a second, substantially identical constitutional suit against the NLRB. Wednesday’s preliminary injunction was also granted without a written decision explaining the court’s reasoning (although one may be forthcoming). SpaceX’s success in halting the ULP proceedings against it shows that regardless of the ultimate merits of the company’s constitutional arguments, its lawsuits have proven to be an effective delay tactic. Labor advocates—still making sense of what the recent Supreme Court term will mean for workers’ rights—will continue to watch both SpaceX cases closely.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
November 26
In today’s news and commentary, NLRB lawyers urge the 3rd Circuit to follow recent district court cases that declined to enjoin Board proceedings; the percentage of unemployed Americans with a college degree reaches its highest level since tracking began in 1992; and a member of the House proposes a bill that would require secret ballot […]
November 25
In today’s news and commentary, OSHA fines Taylor Foods, Santa Fe raises their living wage, and a date is set for a Senate committee to consider Trump’s NLRB nominee. OSHA has issued an approximately $1.1 million dollar fine to Taylor Farms New Jersey, a subsidiary of Taylor Fresh Foods, after identifying repeated and serious safety […]
November 24
Labor leaders criticize tariffs; White House cancels jobs report; and student organizers launch chaperone program for noncitizens.
November 23
Workers at the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority vote to authorize a strike; Washington State legislators consider a bill empowering public employees to bargain over workplace AI implementation; and University of California workers engage in a two-day strike.
November 21
The “Big Three” record labels make a deal with an AI music streaming startup; 30 stores join the now week-old Starbucks Workers United strike; and the Mine Safety and Health Administration draws scrutiny over a recent worker death.
November 20
Law professors file brief in Slaughter; New York appeals court hears arguments about blog post firing; Senate committee delays consideration of NLRB nominee.