John Fry is a student at Harvard Law School.
SpaceX has filed a second lawsuit in Texas challenging the constitutionality of the National Labor Relations Board, after its first suit was transferred from Texas to California last month. The new complaint rehashes two arguments that SpaceX made in its initial suit: that the NLRB’s members and the agency’s administrative law judges are impermissibly shielded from removal by the President.
The new suit is likely a second attempt to have these constitutional claims heard in the Fifth Circuit, which is under increasing scrutiny for its zeal in curtailing federal agencies’ power. SpaceX’s first suit was transferred to California because the underlying unfair labor practice proceedings had a weak connection to the state of Texas, leading a judge in the Southern District of Texas to conclude that venue in Texas was improper. SpaceX’s new suit seeks to halt ongoing ULP proceedings in which the NLRB is challenging the company’s severance agreements and forced arbitration clauses. While these ULP charges were issued in Seattle, the challenged contractual terms apply to SpaceX employees across the country, leading the company to argue that Texas is an appropriate forum for its new suit. Labor law experts will continue to watch both SpaceX suits closely.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
July 22
EDNY strikes down state labor board law; D.C. Circuit applies Loper Bright to NLRB; Joint employer bill reaches the House floor.
July 21
Fifth Circuit transfers an Anheuser-Busch NLRB case to the Eleventh Circuit; a new report makes the case for tripling union membership.
July 20
New York City weighs banning horse carriages despite union opposition; public defenders go on strike; cinema workers stage walkout.
July 17
Canadian wildfires endanger rail workers; 26 Meta employees allege targeted layoffs for those on paid leave; FIFPRO pushes for more rigorous heat protections for players.
July 16
Trump's NLRB nominee set for Senate vote, federal district court grants partial win on WARN Act claims, Brigham and Women's nurses return to work.
July 15
U.S. labor productivity climbs at its fastest pace in decades; a federal judge grants a preliminary injunction to anti-abortion groups challenging Michigan’s civil rights law; and Jackson, Mississippi’s bus workers walk off the job.