Jon Weinberg is a student at Harvard Law School.
Caroline O’Donovan reports for Buzzfeed that named plaintiff Douglas O’Connor is among those who have filed objections to the proposed settlement in O’Connor v. Uber, the federal class action challenging the classification of Uber drivers as independent contractors. O’Connor “is removing his name from the landmark class-action suit for which he was a key plaintiff. He is also replacing Shannon Liss-Riordan, his legal counsel and architect of what he describes as a “disastrous” settlement, with L.A. lawyers Mark Geragos and Brian Kabateck.” O’Connor’s full Declaration can be found here.
The objectors and Liss-Riordan dispute the reasonableness of the proposed settlement. O’Connor contends that “under the agreement, Uber drivers are being sold out and shortchanged by billions of dollars while sacrificing the determination of their classification as employees. Additionally, while the settlement includes a nonmonetary component, those provisions will expire after only two years and serve as mere window dressing for an otherwise deficient agreement.” Wired further notes that “as part of the settlement process, other drivers in the class have [] filed numerous objections with the court over the last month, disputing matters such as how reimbursement costs have been computed and Uber’s disproportionate control over their actions on the job.”
Liss-Riordan continues to defend the adequacy and significance of the proposed settlement. In a previous statement, she outlined the “very significant changes that will improve work conditions for Uber drivers” in addition to the $84 to $100 million monetary settlement, including but not limited to protections against at-will driver termination, the formation of driver associations, and the ability of drivers to actively solicit tips. She believes that “the settlement we have been able to negotiate for Uber drivers throughout California and Massachusetts provides significant benefits – both monetary and non-monetary – that will improve the work lives of the drivers and justifies this compromise result (which will not result in the drivers being reclassified).”
Additionally, Liss-Riordan has stressed that absent a settlement, an appellate court may have invalidated Judge Edward Chen’s expansive class certification finding Uber’s driver arbitration clauses unenforceable. As we’ve previously noted, “three other federal cases were recently dismissed by federal district judges who enforced Uber’s mandatory arbitration clauses.”
OnLabor will continue to monitor developments as the proposed settlement awaits approval or rejection by Judge Chen.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
February 24
DOJ drops Space-X complaint; Unions and agencies respond to Musk
February 23
Trump's attacks on federal workforce make way through courts; Trump NLRB requests Cemex bargaining order; Colorado's Direct Care Workforce Stabilization Board
February 21
In today’s News & Commentary, Trump spending cuts continue to threaten federal workers, and Google AI workers allege violations of labor rights. Trump’s massive federal spending cuts have put millions of workers, both inside and outside the federal government, in jeopardy. Yesterday, thousands of workers at the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs research office were […]
February 20
President Trump's labor secretary pick retreats from some of her pro-labor stances during Senate confirmation hearing and Lynn Rhinehart discusses implications of NLRB and other agency removals.
February 19
In today’s news and commentary, Lori Chavez-Deremer’s confirmation hearing, striking King Soopers workers return to the bargaining table, and UAW members at Rolls-Royce authorize a strike. Lori Chavez-Deremer, President Trump’s nominee for Secretary of Labor, faces a Senate confirmation hearing today. Chavez-Deremer may face more No votes from Republicans than other Trump cabinet members. Rand […]
February 18
In today’s news and commentary, an air traffic union examines the impact of federal aviation worker firings, Southwest Airlines lays off 15% of its corporate workforce, and the NLRB’s General Counsel withdraws Biden-era memos Following the Trump Administration’s dismissal of hundreds of Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) employees, the National Air Traffic Controllers Association (NATCA), a […]