Ted Parker is a student at Harvard Law School and a member of the Labor and Employment Lab.
In today’s news and commentary, more consequences of the Fifth Circuit’s SpaceX decision, AI may undermine white-collar overtime exemptions, and the Sixth Circuit introduces a heightened standard for client harassment of employees.
Law360 reports on the likely practical consequences of the Fifth Circuit’s recent SpaceX decision, which Anjali and Henry covered last week. The main immediate consequence is that “unfair labor practice charges in the Fifth Circuit are blocked.” But that could affect far more workers than just those in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. All an employer needs to take advantage of the ULP block is “plausible ties” to the Fifth Circuit, and “[e]very big employer can go to the Fifth Circuit, every single one, because they have a nationwide presence.” The NLRB may now have to “race” to file in other appeals courts to enforce its orders in ULP cases. Faced with a weakened Board, unions may be advised to forget about filing for elections and instead “organiz[e] to the point that the employer would be confronting a recognitional strike.”
Meanwhile, Bloomberg reports that plaintiffs’ lawyers see an FLSA opportunity in the increased use of AI among white-collar workers. The FLSA mandates overtime pay for workers but grants employers exemptions for certain types of workers. Among those exemptions are white-collar workers whose duties require the exercise of discretion and independent judgment, such as executive, administrative, and professional workers. But “AI’s rapid adoption to automate routine job tasks” in white-collar jobs “is quietly replacing the judgment that once justified exempt status.” Such workers might sue for overtime on the theory that they no longer fit into the traditional FLSA exemptions.
Finally, the Sixth Circuit announced earlier this month that it would break from its sister circuits and long-standing EEOC policy in demanding a heightened standard for client harassment. In Bivens v. Zep, Inc., a unanimous panel addressed an employer’s liability when its employee is harassed by a customer or client. Until now, the standard has been negligence (“knew or should have known”). Now, the Sixth Circuit stands alone in demanding intent—i.e. the company must have “desired to cause [the] harassment or [have been] substantially certain it would result from its actions.” The panel said it would not “lose any sleep” over being the lone circuit to hold this view. In departing from the EEOC’s regulations, the court cited Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, under which it owes no deference to agency interpretations. Critics argue that the court misapplied the agency law principles that it relied on in striking out on its own. Moreover, changing the standard (and creating a circuit split) may have been unnecessary in the first place, as the case likely would have come out the same way under the prior standard.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
September 15
Documents reveal the inner workings of Amazon's union avoidance program; Washington state public sector unions reach tentative deals amid a difficult bargaining cycle; hundreds of Nevada Culinary Union members protest their union's health care changes.
September 14
NCAA and Big Ten file motion to dismiss in former star player's NIL suit; Seventh Circuit rules against former postal worker in discrimination suit.
September 13
Documents released on the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks show that city officials encouraged workers to return to Ground Zero despite knowing the risks of asbestos exposure, and new polls demonstrate continued widespread support for labor unions.
September 10
Amazon workers allege pregnancy discrimination; federal unions challenge USDA reorganization; NYC warns of silicosis risks.
September 9
Wynn Las Vegas employees allege anti-union retaliation; Amazon faces a class action over pregnancy accommodations; H-1B demand plunges following a six-figure visa fee.
September 8
In today’s News and Commentary, workers and unions across America celebrate Labor Day, California’s SEIU Local 1000 prepares for a strike authorization vote, and New York City creates the Office of Worker Power. On Monday, labor unions and workers gathered in cities across the United States in celebration of Labor Day. Parades and rallies took […]