News & Commentary

November 16, 2026

Melinda Meng

Melinda Meng is a student at Harvard Law School.

In today’s News and Commentary, the Second Circuit rules FMCSA must disburse $73 million of withheld highway funds to New York, the Department of Labor’s issuance of a final rule six years after the proposal was withdrawn is upheld, and the Department of Labor issues an enforcement alert regarding inaccurate health plan physician directories.

On Friday, the Second Circuit ruled that the Trump administration must dispense the over $73 million of highway funds it had withheld from New York. The US Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration had alleged that New York was issuing licenses with overlong expiration dates to noncitizens, contravening federal commercial driver’s license requirements. The state argued that the federal government had not established an expiration rule for nonresident commercial licenses and failed to expressly condition the receipt of federal funds on any such requirement. The regulations at issue require applicants to present unexpired employment authorization or lawful presence documents and gives states freedom to issue nonresidents license for up to eight years. The agency argued that the best reading of that requirement implies that the expiration date for such licenses must match the expiration date of those documents, while New York argued that the plain text of the regulations did not contain an expiration-matching requirement. The court agreed with New York that the plain reading of the regulations was clear and found that the agency’s decision to withhold the funding was arbitrary and capricious.

On Friday, the US District Court for the District of Columbia upheld a Labor Department rule requiring unions with more than $40 million in annual receipts to file a new detailed disclosure form. The AFL-CIO sued the department in June for enacting a final rule without seeking public feedback, challenging the propriety of such action under the APA. The Department of Labor had proposed making substantive changes to the financial reporting obligations of large unions in 2020, but then withdrew the proposal after the notice and comment period closed. Nearly six years later, the agency reversed course and finalized the previously withdrawn proposal without further notice and comment. The court found that the agency did not violate the APA as there is no jurisprudence suggesting that an agency’s decision to withdraw a rule wipes the legal effect of a notice-and-comment period away, nor that a lag between the close of the comment period and a rule’s promulgation undermines the procedure. The court remarked that the plaintiff failed to point to any “material intervening events that retroactively rendered its opportunity to comment inadequate” in granting summary judgment to the government.

On Friday, the Department of Labor issued an enforcement alert relating to the accuracy of health plans’ physician directories, noting the presence of errors in plan network provider directories that make it harder for beneficiaries to access covered care. The Employment Retirement Income Security Act, the Affordable Care Act, and the No Surprises Act all require that employers maintain accurate provider directories, but research has shown that an average of 36 percent of providers have incorrect directory information listed. There have been a series of class actions from patients accusing health plans of maintaining these “ghost networks,” leading to increased costs and delays in accessing care. The guidance highlights the shared responsibility borne by healthcare providers and health plan and insurance providers to maintain accurate directory information, outlining best practices for supporting compliance with the law.

More From OnLabor

See more

Enjoy OnLabor’s fresh takes on the day’s labor news, right in your inbox.