Martin Konstantinov is a student at Harvard Law School and a member of the Labor and Employment Lab.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) currently detains around 65,000 people per day, nearly double the number from last year. Although there are over 200 authorized ICE detention centers, most detainees are condensed into a handful of facilities. The government does not run the majority of these centers; private contractors do. In fact, private companies like GEO Group and CoreCivic manage 73% of ICE detention populations, all while making money hand over fist.
Amidst escalating profits and detention numbers, ICE contractors foster center conditions that perpetuate preventable suffering, abuse, and deaths. Private detention facilities have been accused of serious deficiencies in medical care with fatal outcomes, negligence toward their populations, sexual abuse, and draconian punishments. They have also faced allegations of forced unpaid labor in violation of several federal and state laws, including the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA). In response, contractors have tried to play a near-endless game of delay and deny. And it has worked—for the most part.
On February 25, 2026, in GEO Group v. Menocal, the Supreme Court held that the denial of GEO Group’s defense against plaintiffs was not immediately appealable. In a unanimous 9-0 opinion, Justice Kagan concluded that an immediate appeal under the collateral-order doctrine did not extend to the contractor’s defense.
The case itself originated over a decade earlier. In 2014, a prospective class of over 60,000 people who were at one point detained at GEO Group’s Aurora facility filed a complaint in the District of Colorado and alleged that the contractor violated the TVPA by threatening detainees with punishment, including solitary confinement, unless they worked for the facility without pay or for $1 per day. One year later, GEO Group’s motion to dismiss was denied. For the first time, the contractor requested an interlocutory appeal, which the district court rejected. In 2017, two classes were certified. GEO Group again appealed, but the Tenth Circuit affirmed the ruling in 2018. GEO Group subsequently petitioned the Supreme Court for certiorari, but was denied.
In 2022, following four years of discovery, the district court ruled on both parties’ motions for summary judgment. As part of its decision, the court rejected GEO Group’s argument that it was merely following ICE’s instructions and could not be sued. GEO Group once again filed an interlocutory appeal in the Tenth Circuit. In 2024, ten years after the case’s inception, the Tenth Circuit dismissed the appeal for lack of appellate jurisdiction, holding that the district court’s ruling did not qualify for immediate review. GEO once again sought certiorari and was granted certiorari.
The Menocal decision is incredibly technical. The Court began by examining the principal case that establishes the contractor’s defense, Yearsley v. W.A. Ross Construction. In Yearsley, the Court held that a private contractor may be protected from liability when performing work for the government, provided that the government had the authority to undertake the work and the contractor acted pursuant to valid government authorization. From the outset, the Court drew a clear distinction: “Yearsley provides a defense to liability, not an immunity to suit.”
An immunity from suit protects defendants from litigation itself. Its rejection subsequently qualifies for an immediate appeal under the collateral-order doctrine, a long line of Supreme Court cases that created an exception to the general rule that appellate courts can only review final decisions of district courts. Conversely, a defense to liability is a claim on the merits: a party asserts some reason as to why their conduct was not unlawful. Whereas an immunity makes it such that the defendant does not need to answer for their conduct in court, the Court reasoned that a defense “offers something different, and of lesser value:” an answer to the alleged conduct so as to escape liability.
Unlike a defense from suit, a party’s immunity does not turn on whether its conduct was lawful. When a party’s defense is denied, the Court explained, the right to contest that ruling on the merits can be effectively vindicated after a trial. The Court therefore concluded that any appeal of an order denying the application of the Yearsley defense could only be reviewed after a district court’s final judgment—the resolution of the case on the merits.
Applying the defense-immunity distinction to the plaintiffs’ case, the Court easily justified denying GEO Group’s appeal. The Court concluded that GEO Group was making the argument for a defense on the merits by using Yearsley and saying it complied with the law—the government authorized the contractor’s conduct—while otherwise cloaking it in the language of an immunity from suit so as to justify its appeal. The Court did not allow GEO Group to do so.
Make no mistake about it, the decision is a win—all too rare—for victims of forced labor who seek to hold contractors like GEO Group accountable for their illegal conduct. But the case is also a sobering reminder of just how long plaintiffs must wait for their day in court. In its decision, the Court emphasized that there were good reasons to keep the exception to the collateral-order rule narrow. Doing otherwise would allow for “piecemeal appeals,” whereas finality “promotes the efficient administration of justice and preserves the proper balance between trial and appellate courts.” It is better that contractors will now not be able to immediately appeal the denial of this particular defense in other cases, but that does not foreclose them from taking advantage of the numerous levers of litigation to continuously delay claims from being placed in front of juries and rights from potential vindication. The Court’s decision may promote a more efficient administration of justice, but when the result looks something like shaving off a couple years from cases that themselves routinely take more than a decade, the Court’s promise will certainly ring hollow for those most affected by abuses of power.
The case throws into sharper relief the consequences of courts’ inadequate attempts to fulfill their mandate as institutions that preserve rights and hold wrongdoers accountable. Even if the Menocal plaintiffs win at trial and receive the millions of dollars owed to them as damages, as plaintiffs in related cases have eventually been awarded, they would have now missed out on the benefits of that money for over twelve years, all while GEO Group has reported billions in annual revenue and expanded at record pace. Any judgment cannot retroactively repair the difficulties plaintiffs have and continue to face in the years since they were detained. And though the Court’s decision in Menocal may help a future class of plaintiffs avoid the particular Yearsley pitfall, it does not solve the deeper problem: defendants’ games of delay and deny should largely continue to work as designed.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
November 16
FMCSA ordered to disburse $73 million in withheld highway funds to New York; Department of Labor final rule regarding large union financial disclosures issued six years after initial withdrawal is upheld; Department of Labor issues enforcement alert for physician ghost networks maintained by health plans.
November 15
Unions oppose Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader; Rockstar staff vote on unionization ahead of Grand Theft Auto VI’s release; New Jersey Education Association faces federal investigation.
November 12
Harvard graduate students go on strike; New York city mayor prepares to negotiate with the city's largest public union; the Trump administration proposes stringent rules for workers seeking benefits.
November 11
MIT grad union avoids strike, Colombian union clashes with Nestlé, and DOL proposes stricter UI requirements.
November 10
The White House nominates new EEOC and FTC commissioners; casino workers at Encore Boston Harbor ratify a new contract ending a two-month strike.
November 9
Democratic gains in Congress likely spell the end of the Protect College Sports Act; IBEW endorses the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act.