John Fry is a student at Harvard Law School.
In today’s news and commentary, the NLRB’s limited powers enable Starbucks to chill union resurgence; Ed Sheeran draws criticism for promoting Starbucks; Teamsters demand safer conditions after heat-related death; visual effects workers file for union elections; and NLRB clarifies standard for retaliation.
The National Labor Relations Board’s limited remedial powers may enable Starbucks to get away with union-busting and throw cold water on the ongoing national surge in union activity, according to new analysis from the Guardian. While the Board’s regional offices have charged Starbucks with thousands of labor law violations, the National Labor Relations Act does not allow the Board to impose fines. Professor Sachs also notes that “[t]he remedy that’s ordered for a failure to bargain in good faith is an order to bargain more. That just doesn’t work.” The few concrete remedies which are available, such as reinstatement for wrongfully fired workers, often take years to obtain. Starbucks has yet to reach a contract with any of its 340-plus unionized stores, and at least 9,000 stores remain non-union.
In related news, workers are criticizing singer Ed Sheeran for working a shift at a Seattle Starbucks, where he promoted his forthcoming album and the chain’s popular pumpkin spice latte. Starbucks Workers United claims the company engaged in “massive union-busting” at the location where Sheeran appeared.
Members of Teamsters Local 667 are demanding heat safety improvements after a Kroger worker died on the job on Friday. Union leaders say that Tony Rufus was sweating heavily and asking for water before he collapsed in a grocery distribution warehouse. Per the union, workers at the warehouse receive a 15-minute break every two hours, and Rufus worked in a department without air conditioning. While the union is seeking more breaks and cold beverages to ease the heat, Bloomberg Law reports that OSHA has not yet decided the details of a long-awaited heat safety rule.
In the latest installment of summer labor activity in Hollywood, Disney visual effects workers have filed for a union election, following the example of Marvel VFX workers who filed earlier this month. If successful, the workers would be the first VFX members of IATSE, a union representing a broad swath of workers in film production. The workers seek to capitalize on a summer of inter-union solidarity between striking writers, actors, hotel workers, and others.
The National Labor Relations Board has clarified its standard for illegal anti-union retaliation. In its Intertape Polymer Corp. decision, the Board reaffirmed that the Wright Line standard from 1980 still governs retaliation cases, despite a Trump-era decision which appeared to modify the legal test. Wright Line requires a showing that an employee’s protected union activity was a “motivating factor” in an adverse employment action taken against them. After such a showing, the burden is on the employer to establish that it would have taken the action in the absence of the employee’s protected activity. If the employer cannot meet this burden, the Board will find that the employer committed an unfair labor practice.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
March 16
Starbucks' union negotiations are resurrected; jobs data is released.
March 15
A U.S. District Court issues a preliminary injunction against the Department of Veterans Affairs for terminating its collective bargaining agreement, and SEIU files a lawsuit against DHS for effectively terminating immigrant workers at Boston Logan International Airport.
March 13
Republican Senators urge changes on OSHA heat standard; OpenAI and building trades announce partnership on data center construction; forced labor investigations could lead to new tariffs
March 12
EPA terminates contract with second-largest union; Florida advances bill restricting public sector unions; Trump administration seeks Supreme Court assistance in TPS termination.
March 11
The partial government shutdown results in TSA agents losing their first full paycheck; the Fifth Circuit upholds the certification of a class of former United Airline workers who were placed on unpaid leave for declining to receive the COVID-19 vaccine for religious reasons during the pandemic; and an academic group files a lawsuit against the State Department over a policy that revokes and denies visas to noncitizens for their work in fact-checking and content moderation.
March 10
Court rules Kari Lake unlawfully led USAGM, voiding mass layoffs; Florida Senate passes bill tightening union recertification rules; Fifth Circuit revives whistleblower suit against Lockheed Martin.