Melissa Greenberg is a student at Harvard Law School.
Yesterday, in a 2-1 decision, the Fifth Circuit vacated the fiduciary rule, which was issued by the Obama Administration. The Fifth Circuit found that the Department of Labor had acted arbitrarily and capriciously under the Administrative Procedures Act and the Department of Labor’s interpretation of “investment advice fiduciary” in the Employee Retirement Income Security Act should not be accorded deference under Chevron. The Fifth Circuit’s opinion was released in the same week as a Tenth Circuit decision, which upheld the rule, resulting in a circuit split. The fiduciary rule heightens the standard that brokers must adhere to when advising a client on retirement products by requiring brokers to act in their client’s best interest instead of simply requiring that they recommend “suitable” investments. The Trump Administration, which had allowed the rule’s best interest standard to go into effect last year while delaying implementation of other aspects of the rule, declined to say how it would respond to the court’s decision. Read more here.
President Trump’s decision to impose tariffs on steel and aluminum has continued to provoke controversy. In the Nation, Doug Henwood argues labor should not support Trump’s tariffs. He states, these policies “will do little if anything to help the steel industry, could harm steel-using industries, will probably provoke retaliations that will leave everyone worse off, and will add a fresh dose of bellicosity to a world already overdosing on it.” In the New Yorker, Benjamin Wallace-Wells examines the ways in which the American steel industry differs in the North and South. “The story of the U.S. steel industry is still set in the North, even as the mills themselves have moved South, and so it sustains a nostalgia that the industry itself cannot.” He notes the lack of response to Trump’s tariffs in the South. He writes, “the steel industry has come to stand in for a certain twentieth-century economic model, in which skilled industrial jobs could last a career and sustain a middle-class life. But that model did not survive the transition to the South—the work has grown less dangerous but also more automated.”
The Upshot asks, “Will Employment Keep Growing?: Disabled Workers Offer a Clue.” Workers between age 25 and 54 years old, or prime-age workers, who report not working due to health reasons has declined by seven percent since the middle of 2014. Economists had been troubled by the increase of workers in this category. People reporting a disability as their reason for not working started to increase before the recession, increased more rapidly in reaction to the 2001 and 2008 recessions, and continued to increase even as the economy rebounded. However, since the middle of 2014, this trend has started to reverse. Increased employment for this group suggests workforce participation could continue to grow. Read more here.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
April 21
Bryan Johnson’s ULP saga before the NLRB continues; top law firms opt to appease the EEOC in its anti-DEI demands.
April 20
In today’s news and commentary, the Supreme Court rules for Cornell employees in an ERISA suit, the Sixth Circuit addresses whether the EFAA applies to a sexual harassment claim, and DOGE gains access to sensitive labor data on immigrants. On Thursday, the Supreme Court made it easier for employees to bring ERISA suits when their […]
April 18
Two major New York City unions endorse Cuomo for mayor; Committee on Education and the Workforce requests an investigation into a major healthcare union’s spending; Unions launch a national pro bono legal network for federal workers.
April 17
Utahns sign a petition supporting referendum to repeal law prohibiting public sector collective bargaining; the US District Court for the District of Columbia declines to dismiss claims filed by the AFL-CIO against several government agencies; and the DOGE faces reports that staffers of the agency accessed the NLRB’s sensitive case files.
April 16
7th Circuit questions the relevance of NLRB precedent after Loper Bright, unions seek to defend silica rule, and Abrego Garcia's union speaks out.
April 15
In today’s news and commentary, SAG-AFTRA reaches a tentative agreement, AFT sues the Trump Administration, and California offers its mediation services to make up for federal cuts. SAG-AFTRA, the union representing approximately 133,000 commercial actors and singers, has reached a tentative agreement with advertisers and advertising agencies. These companies were represented in contract negotiations by […]