
Jason Vazquez is a staff attorney at the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. He graduated from Harvard Law School in 2023. His writing on this blog reflects his personal views and should not be attributed to the IBT.
Following 18 months of negotiation, direct intervention on the part of Mayor Wu, and a one-day strike, more than 200 employees at Boston’s distinguished Museum of Fine Arts ratified a CBA on Tuesday. The contract is the employees’ first collective agreement since they voted in a landslide to join the UAW in 2020, one of many cultural institutions to unionize during the pandemic.
In exciting NLRB news, GC Abruzzo announced yesterday that her office had filed a motion requesting that the Board overturn its holding in Ex-Cell-O, which is an important doctrine that operates to significantly undermine the agency’s remedial powers. Abruzzo expressed interest in revisiting the policy in the “stunning” remedies memo she issued last September, and doing so may have important ramifications for the labor movement.
Section 8(a)(5) of the NLRA obligates employers to bargain in good faith with a union representing their employees. But, as Abruzzo recognized in her announcement, extant Board law enables employers to evade this legal obligation, often for several years, for they face few, if any, meaningful consequences for doing so. This is because the conventional remedy designed to redress an employer’s unlawful refusal to negotiate consists of a mere bargaining order, which in effect instructs the employer to do what it was already statutory required to do. This remedial deficiency cripples unions’ ability to organize new workers and deliver gains to their existing members. In view of these shortcomings, the Ex-Cell-O Board contemplated but ultimately declined to fashion a compensatory remedy for violations of an employer’s duty to bargain. Such a remedy would have obligated an employer to compensate its employees for any financial losses they sustained as a result of its unlawful delay tactics at the bargaining table, based on an estimate of the wage and benefit levels the employees would, or might, have secured had the employer complied with the good-faith bargaining envisaged by the Act. Although the Ex-Cell-O Board identified, correctly enough, that existing remedies for 8(a)(5) violations are “inadequate,” it concluded that it was not statutorily authorized to fashion a compensatory remedy in this context. Abruzzo’s motion asks the Board to reverse that holding.
The GC’s motion may prove consequential, for it has the potential to meaningfully expand the agency’s remedial arsenal, the deficiency of which generations of labor law scholars have decried as one of the “major flaws in the current NLRA regime.” Last September, Professor Sachs observed that “if the Board does a fraction of the things Abruzzo calls for” in her remedies memo, she would become “one of the most consequential GCs in NLRB history.” On Friday, by urging the Board to revisit Ex-Cell-O, Abruzzo took a step in that direction.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
May 5
Unemployment rates for Black women go up under Trump; NLRB argues Amazon lacks standing to challenge captive audience meeting rule; Teamsters use Wilcox's reinstatement orders to argue against injunction.
May 4
In today’s news and commentary, DOL pauses the 2024 gig worker rule, a coalition of unions, cities, and nonprofits sues to stop DOGE, and the Chicago Teachers Union reaches a remarkable deal. On May 1, the Department of Labor announced it would pause enforcement of the Biden Administration’s independent contractor classification rule. Under the January […]
May 2
Immigrant detainees win class certification; Missouri sick leave law in effect; OSHA unexpectedly continues Biden-Era Worker Heat Rule
May 1
SEIU 721 concludes a 48-hour unfair labor practice strike; NLRB Administrative Law Judge holds that Starbucks committed a series of unfair labor practices at a store in Philadelphia; AFSCME and UPTE members at the University of California are striking.
April 30
In today’s news and commentary, SEIU seeks union rights for rideshare drivers in California, New Jersey proposes applying the ABC Test, and Board officials push back on calls for layoffs. In California, Politico reports that an SEIU-backed bill that would allow rideshare drivers to join unions has passed out of committee, “clear[ing] its first hurdle.” […]
April 29
In today’s news and commentary, CFPB mass layoffs paused again, Mine Safety agency rejects union intervention, and postdoctoral researchers petition for union election. A temporary pause on mass firings at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has been restored. After a trial court initially blocked the administration from mass firings, the appeals court modified that […]