Jon Weinberg is a student at Harvard Law School.
The Recorder reports that Uber has “successfully persuaded a private arbitrator that a California driver for the transportation company is an independent contractor, not an employee, in the first arbitration in the United States to test that issue.” While drivers continue to challenge Uber’s mandatory arbitration agreements in court, the arbitrator’s decision represents the outcome of the first of what could become many individual challenges by drivers asserting proper classification as employees, if arbitration agreements are enforced.
Arbitrator Michael Marcus applied the Borello test, which is used to determine proper classification under California law and gives considerable weight to the control exercised by the alleged employer over the worker. After considering the Borello factors in light of the facts and circumstances of the particular driver’s relationship with Uber, Marcus concluded that Uber lacks the requisite control over the particular driver, or any comparable driver, to be considered an employer. He particularly noted that Uber does not guarantee rides, require minimum activity time, prevent drivers from driving for competitors, or direct driver routes. Marcus’ conclusion contrasts with that of Professor Sachs and others.
Shannon Liss-Riordan, who continues to litigate the most prominent driver classification cases against Uber and has yet to file a case for arbitration due to pending litigation, told The Recorder that individual arbitrations are insignificant and lack precedential value:
In arbitration, you may win some and lose some, depending on what arbitrator you get in front of,” Liss-Riordan said in an email. “This is just a very inefficient system for adjudicating a widespread issue.
While the driver in question will not be classified as an employee and receive the corresponding benefits or protections, Liss-Riordan indicates the robust efforts of driver advocates will continue unabated.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
May 13
House Republicans push for vote on the SCORE Act; Wells Fargo wins 401(k) forfeiture appeal; Georgia passes portable benefits bill.
May 12
Trump administration proposes expanding fertility care benefits; Connecticut passes employment legislation; NFL referees ratify new collective bargaining agreement.
May 11
NLRB Judge finds UPS violated federal labor law; Tennessee bans certain noncompetes; and Colorado passes a bill restricting AI price- and wage-setting
May 10
Workers at the Long Island Rail Road threaten to strike, and referees at the National Football League reach a collective bargaining agreement.
May 9
HGSU wraps up its third week on strike and economists find that firms tend to target workers with “wage premiums” for AI replacement.
May 7
DOL drops litigation of Biden-era overtime rule; EEOC sues NYT for discrimination against white male employee; New Jersey finalizes employee classification rule.