In a case that touches upon some of the same issues at stake in Friedrichs v. CTA, U.S. District Judge Stephen Wilson recently dismissed a First Amendment challenge to California’s public employment scheme brought by California teachers union members. The plaintiffs in the suit — Bain v. CTA — contended that they were “‘effectively compelled’ to relinquish their First Amendment right not to speak because they cannot enjoy substantial employment-related benefits and union voting rights without making contributions that fund the unions’ political and ideological activities.” However, Judge Wilson found that presenting this choice to public employees was not so coercive as to implicate First Amendment concerns, and moreover, that authorizing unions to present this choice was the only state action at issue. Notably, Bain was backed by the same team behind Vergara v. California — StudentsFirst and attorneys from Gibson Dunn — which is currently on appeal. The order is available here.
Speaking of teachers unions, does Hillary Clinton deserve their endorsement? Evan Halper of the Los Angeles Times suggests perhaps not. Halper notes that although Clinton is “a dear friend of a fiery teachers union leader [Randi Weingarten], . . . speaks out against the bombardment of standardized testing that dismays educators, and . . . never misses a chance to say how enamored she is with those who teach,” some rank-and-file union members are concerned that she has failed to distance herself from the accountability and choice-focused education policies of the current administration — policies that are championed by a number of wealthy Clinton supporters. And continuation of the status quo, argued Massachusetts Teachers Association President Barbara Madeloni, will simply not do: “Our members want to hear that candidates understand that so-called education reform is really an attack on public education.”
Late last week, a federal district judge declined to dismiss entirely claims brought against McDonald’s for alleged wage and hour violations in its franchises. U.S. District Judge James Donato found that although “McDonald’s has the ability to exert considerable pressure on its franchisees,” it nonetheless failed to meet the California standard for employer control; the judge also dismissed plaintiffs’ negligence claims. However, given the named plaintiffs’ declarations that they believed McDonald’s to be their employer, the judge found that a reasonable jury could conclude that McDonald’s was liable under an ostensible agency theory. Courtesy of Politico, the order is available here.
Finally, today’s New York Times Opinion Pages (whether print or virtual) offer a thoughtful commentary on the value of “low-skilled” work. Brittany Bronson, who triples as an adjunct English professor, restaurant server, and contributing opinion writer, laments that “[w]e’re raised, in the culture of American capitalism, to believe . . . that the value of work is defined by the complexity of the task and not the execution of it, that certain types of work are not worthy of devoting a lifetime to.” Yet Bronson notes that “on some nights [in the casino restaurant in which she works], when [her] multitasking, memory and body are in sync, when [she] find[s] [her]self moving calmly around a room full of slightly buzzed and cheerful people, [she] feel[s] confident that not every person can do the job as well as [she] can.” Accordingly, she contends that “[t]he terms ‘unskilled’ and ‘low-skilled labor’ contradict the care and precision with which [her] co-workers, who have a variety of educational backgrounds and language fluencies, execute their tasks.” And this misclassification, she argues, is not just an issue of semantics: “The labels ‘low-skilled’ or ‘unskilled’ workers — the largest demographic being adult women and minorities” — contribute to “poverty-level wages, erratic schedules, the absence of retirement planning, health benefits, paid sick or family leave and the constant threat of being replaced.”
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
November 17
Amazon workers in Canada win company's first union contract in North America; NY law gives employees access to personnel records; D.C. Circuit looks to overturn Trump joint employer rule
November 16
FMCSA ordered to disburse $73 million in withheld highway funds to New York; Department of Labor final rule regarding large union financial disclosures issued six years after initial withdrawal is upheld; Department of Labor issues enforcement alert for physician ghost networks maintained by health plans.
November 15
Unions oppose Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader; Rockstar staff vote on unionization ahead of Grand Theft Auto VI’s release; New Jersey Education Association faces federal investigation.
November 12
Harvard graduate students go on strike; New York city mayor prepares to negotiate with the city's largest public union; the Trump administration proposes stringent rules for workers seeking benefits.
November 11
MIT grad union avoids strike, Colombian union clashes with Nestlé, and DOL proposes stricter UI requirements.
November 10
The White House nominates new EEOC and FTC commissioners; casino workers at Encore Boston Harbor ratify a new contract ending a two-month strike.