Andrew Strom is the Legal and Policy Director for the American Guild of Musical Artists (AGMA), and has been contributing to OnLabor since 2014. The views he expresses on this blog are his personal opinions and should not be attributed to AGMA.
Andrew Strom is Associate General Counsel of SEIU Local 32BJ.
All of us have had the experience of the government spending our tax dollars to promote ideas we oppose. Most of us have probably not thought that these expenditures violate the First Amendment’s prohibition against “abridging the freedom of speech.” Supreme Court justices across the political spectrum have unanimously agreed that the government’s own speech is immune from First Amendment challenges. In other words, if you are a pacifist, you do not have a viable First Amendment claim against the federal government for using your tax dollars to promote the military. On the other hand, the Court has held that there is a First Amendment claim when the government requires individuals to subsidize messages they disagree with expressed by a private entity.
The case of Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association rests on this distinction, but it is a distinction that makes little sense. The Friedrichs plaintiffs embrace the quotation from Jefferson that “to compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves is sinful and tyrannical.” But, if you truly believe that it is tyrannical to compel people to provide financial support for ideas they disagree with, then all taxes are a form of tyranny. The justification given most often for treating the government’s own speech differently from the government compelling subsidization of a private entity’s speech is that the government is “accountable to the electorate and the political process for its advocacy.” But, the government is equally accountable when it compels the plaintiffs in Friedrichs to pay fair share fees. If the electorate thinks that the fair share system is a bad idea, they can vote to change that system.
Recent events in Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin demonstrate that this is not merely a theoretical possibility. In the last few years, these states decided to eliminate fair share requirements. The Friedrichs plaintiffs are simply disgruntled because in California they can’t win the argument to repeal fair share. But this places them in no different position than socialists in Texas who object to their tax dollars funding a curriculum that teaches schoolchildren “economics, with an emphasis on the free enterprise system and its benefits.” It is also no answer to say that fair share fees are different from taxes because they are not uniformly imposed upon all citizens. The Supreme Court rejected a similar argument in Johanns v. Livestock Marketing Association, where it upheld a federal program that required beef producers to fund marketing efforts. In Johanns, the Court stated that the First Amendment analysis is not affected when the government raises money through targeted assessments rather than through general taxes.
So, the Friedrichs plaintiffs would have no First Amendment claim if the State of California imposed a special assessment on all schoolteachers and used that money to promote educational policies that they oppose. In light of that, as Will Baude has suggested, if the Court is going to reexamine long settled principles in Friedrichs, it owes us a better explanation of why there is a First Amendment right in the first place.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
November 19
Harvard academic workers end strike without contract; Reuters journalists authorize a strike; Spirit Airlines’ sale of employee data to Google for AI training approved.
November 18
Judge vacates foreign-student visa limits; DOL proposes QPAM relief; Supreme Court declines Nexstar appeal.
November 17
Amazon workers in Canada win company's first union contract in North America; NY law gives employees access to personnel records; D.C. Circuit looks to overturn Trump joint employer rule
November 16
FMCSA ordered to disburse $73 million in withheld highway funds to New York; Department of Labor final rule regarding large union financial disclosures issued six years after initial withdrawal is upheld; Department of Labor issues enforcement alert for physician ghost networks maintained by health plans.
November 15
Unions oppose Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader; Rockstar staff vote on unionization ahead of Grand Theft Auto VI’s release; New Jersey Education Association faces federal investigation.
November 12
Harvard graduate students go on strike; New York city mayor prepares to negotiate with the city's largest public union; the Trump administration proposes stringent rules for workers seeking benefits.