Meredith Gudesblatt is a student at Harvard Law School and a member of the Labor and Employment Lab.
In Today’s News and Commentary, a strike by Long Island Railroad employees is temporarily averted, the Department of Justice sues Rhode Island over a minority teachers student loan repayment program, and University of California employees sue the Trump Administration for financial coercion.
On Tuesday, in response to a request from a coalition of unions, President Trump issued an executive order establishing an emergency board to review a dispute between the Long Island Rail Road and the unions. The railroad’s workforce is among the highest paid in the nation, and while representatives of other Metropolitan Transit Authority employees have already agreed to a 9.5 percent wage increase over the next three years, the unions want an additional 6.5 percent increase in a fourth year to help keep pace with inflation. Contract negotiations have been in mediation for over a year, but in August, the National Mediation Board released the unions from ongoing mediation. Before asking for assistance from President Trump, the unions had planned to go on strike yesterday for the first time in over 30 years. Whether the presidential emergency board will result in a contract or simply postpone the strike until next year remains to be seen. But for now, riders of the biggest commuter rail service in the United States can breathe a sigh of relief.
Meanwhile, Bloomberg reports that the Department of Justice filed suit against Rhode Island for race discrimination in public employment related to a student loan forgiveness program designed to boost teacher diversity. The case is United States v. State of Rhode Island. The Educators of Color Loan Forgiveness Program, established in 2021 after the Rhode Island Department of Education took control of the Providence Public School District, allows teachers of color (defined as those who identify as Black, Hispanic, Asian, American Indian, or people of two or more races) to receive student loan repayments of up to $25,000. The suit alleges that excluding White teachers is “blatant race discrimination” in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. In July, the EEOC found “reasonable cause to believe” the student loan program was in violation of Title VII. The Department of Justice seeks an injunction blocking the program and an award of relief to non-minority teachers who were ineligible.
Lastly, a group of 21 labor unions representing over 100,000 faculty and student employees in the University of California education system have filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California against the Trump Administration over its weaponization of Title VI and financial threats against academic institutions in an attempt to stifle views it opposes. The Los Angeles Times has described the unions as “not waiting on leaders.” Up until now, the University of California has limited itself exclusively to negotiations, but the president of the UCLA Faculty Association expressed hope that UC administration would join them in this suit. The 123-page complaint alleges that the funding cuts and $1.2 billion fine levied against UCLA violates employees’ free speech and due process rights, as well as the 10th Amendment due to the Trump Administration’s attempt to take over and micromanage the UC system. It also describes the Trump Administration as “[d]etermined to exert ideological control over the nation’s core institutions,” following a playbook “employed by autocratic movements around the world—be it Hungary, Turkey, or Brazil.” The Plaintiffs are represented by Altshuler Berzon LLP, Democracy Forward Foundation, and the American Association of University Professors, among others.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
December 22
Worker-friendly legislation enacted in New York; UW Professor wins free speech case; Trucking company ordered to pay $23 million to Teamsters.
December 21
Argentine unions march against labor law reform; WNBA players vote to authorize a strike; and the NLRB prepares to clear its backlog.
December 19
Labor law professors file an amici curiae and the NLRB regains quorum.
December 18
New Jersey adopts disparate impact rules; Teamsters oppose railroad merger; court pauses more shutdown layoffs.
December 17
The TSA suspends a labor union representing 47,000 officers for a second time; the Trump administration seeks to recruit over 1,000 artificial intelligence experts to the federal workforce; and the New York Times reports on the tumultuous changes that U.S. labor relations has seen over the past year.
December 16
Second Circuit affirms dismissal of former collegiate athletes’ antitrust suit; UPS will invest $120 million in truck-unloading robots; Sharon Block argues there are reasons for optimism about labor’s future.