Jack Goldsmith is the Learned Hand Professor of Law at Harvard Law School, where he teaches and writes about national security law, international law, internet law, and, recently, labor history. Before coming to Harvard, Professor Goldsmith served as Assistant Attorney General, Office of Legal Counsel from 2003-2004, and Special Counsel to the Department of Defense from 2002-2003.
Last month I outlined three “procedural hurdles” to affirmance in Mulhall: a possible absence of a private right of action, inadequate pleading, and mootness. In a good essay just posted on SSRN, Thomas Frampton, a Berkeley law grad and a law clerk for Judge Jack Weinstein (E.D.N.Y.), has identified a potential fourth problem: Respondent (and plaintiff) Martin Mulhall lacks standing to bring the lawsuit, thus depriving the court of subject matter jurisdiction. As Frampton notes, the district court in 2009 accepted a version of this argument, but the Eleventh Circuit reversed, concluding that “Mulhall has a legally cognizable associational interest . . . at imminent risk of invasion, because Mardi Gras’ provision of considerable and varied organizing assistance pursuant to the MOA will substantially increase the likelihood that Mulhall will be unionized against his will.”
Thomas analyzes and rejects this and a number of other possible arguments for standing. His most trenchant point, I think, is that Mulhall cannot be “unionized against his will” or suffer prospective associational harm from the enhanced likelihood of unionization as a result of the neutrality agreement because Florida is a right-to-work state, which means that Mulhall cannot be compelled to join the union or pay a “fair share fee” for collective bargaining expenses incurred on his behalf.
Neither Petitioner’s briefs nor the amicus briefs on its behalf raise the standing issue. But of course standing goes to subject matter jurisdiction and can be raised at any time, including by the Court sua sponte.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
November 19
Harvard academic workers end strike without contract; Reuters journalists authorize a strike; Spirit Airlines’ sale of employee data to Google for AI training approved.
November 18
Judge vacates foreign-student visa limits; DOL proposes QPAM relief; Supreme Court declines Nexstar appeal.
November 17
Amazon workers in Canada win company's first union contract in North America; NY law gives employees access to personnel records; D.C. Circuit looks to overturn Trump joint employer rule
November 16
FMCSA ordered to disburse $73 million in withheld highway funds to New York; Department of Labor final rule regarding large union financial disclosures issued six years after initial withdrawal is upheld; Department of Labor issues enforcement alert for physician ghost networks maintained by health plans.
November 15
Unions oppose Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader; Rockstar staff vote on unionization ahead of Grand Theft Auto VI’s release; New Jersey Education Association faces federal investigation.
November 12
Harvard graduate students go on strike; New York city mayor prepares to negotiate with the city's largest public union; the Trump administration proposes stringent rules for workers seeking benefits.