Today, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Mach Mining, L.L.C. v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, a case which will determine whether federal trial courts can oversee the EEOC’s pre-lawsuit settlement procedures. The EEOC has a statutory obligation to try to negotiate an end to unlawful employment practices prior to bringing a bias case. To date, lower courts have been split on whether a company may challenge the adequacy of this “good faith conciliation” effort, and move to dismiss a case on that basis. An argument preview from Julie Goldscheid is available at SCOTUSBlog. As Professor Goldscheid writes: “This case raises important questions about access to judicial review in discrimination cases. It highlights the sharply divided views held by employers and workers regarding the role of employment discrimination litigation in advancing workplace equality.”
The New York Times highlights a recent study connecting union membership with higher levels of subjective well-being. Analyzing data collected from the World Values Survey in the United States, the report noticed that “union members are more satisfied with their lives than those who are not members and […] the substantive effect of union membership on life satisfaction is large and rivals other common predictors of quality of life.” These boosts to satisfaction were found to exist, independent of income. Study authors Prof. Patrick Flavin (Baylor University) and Prof. Gregory Shufeldt (University of Arkansas, Little Rock) noted: “Simply put, if one goal of labor unions is to boost the quality of life for their members, our study provides empirical evidence that they are succeeding.”
The L.A. Times reports that a dispute between commercial producers and the Teamsters Local 399 union have escalated, with the Teamsters voting to strike if an agreement is not reached by the end of the month. A walkout would represent the union’s first Hollywood strike in nearly two decades, and would effectively shut down commercial production in L.A. The union contract expires on January 31st, and negotiations will continue through the contract period.
The Wall Street Journal editorial pages discuss Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker’s relationship to proposed right-to-work legislation. Wisconsin Senate leaders have discussed introducing a right-to-work bill. Recently, however, Governor Walker has called such proposals a “distraction,” noting that there are “lot of things that are going to keep the legislature preoccupied for a while,” like taxes and education. Currently, 24 states have passed right-to-work legislation, which broadly prohibits union security contracts between labor unions and employees.
As one of his last acts in office, outgoing Illinois governor Pat Quinn left an executive order increasing minimum wage for all state vendors and subcontractors. Governor Quinn is succeeded by Bruce Rauner: Rauner’s team has noted that they will “review all of the former Governor’s executive orders.” The Chicago Tribune reports.
Daily News & Commentary
Start your day with our roundup of the latest labor developments. See all
July 4
The DOL scraps a Biden-era proposed rule to end subminimum wages for disabled workers; millions will lose access to Medicaid and SNAP due to new proof of work requirements; and states step up in the noncompete policy space.
July 3
California compromises with unions on housing; 11th Circuit rules against transgender teacher; Harvard removes hundreds from grad student union.
July 2
Block, Nanda, and Nayak argue that the NLRA is under attack, harming democracy; the EEOC files a motion to dismiss a lawsuit brought by former EEOC Commissioner Jocelyn Samuels; and SEIU Local 1000 strikes an agreement with the State of California to delay the state's return-to-office executive order for state workers.
July 1
In today’s news and commentary, the Department of Labor proposes to roll back minimum wage and overtime protections for home care workers, a federal judge dismissed a lawsuit by public defenders over a union’s Gaza statements, and Philadelphia’s largest municipal union is on strike for first time in nearly 40 years. On Monday, the U.S. […]
June 30
Antidiscrimination scholars question McDonnell Douglas, George Washington University Hospital bargained in bad faith, and NY regulators defend LPA dispensary law.
June 29
In today’s news and commentary, Trump v. CASA restricts nationwide injunctions, a preliminary injunction continues to stop DOL from shutting down Job Corps, and the minimum wage is set to rise in multiple cities and states. On Friday, the Supreme Court held in Trump v. CASA that universal injunctions “likely exceed the equitable authority that […]